In the heart of Indianapolis, the Butler Bulldogs Basketball team exemplifies the essence of grit, determination, and unwavering team spirit at the iconic Hinkle Fieldhouse. Renowned for their Cinderella runs and March Madness heroics, this illustrious program has captured the hearts of fans and solidified its place in collegiate basketball history. As we construct the all-time starting five, we pay tribute to not just players, but to legends who have donned the Butler blue and white, leaving an indelible mark on the court.
The Butler Bulldogs’ basketball style is characterized by iconic buzzer-beaters and relentless defensive stands, embodying what is known as “The Butler Way”—a dedication to selflessness, passion, and excellence. Join us as we embark on a journey through time, revisiting the careers that transformed Butler from a mid-major team into a national powerhouse. This retrospective is more than just a walk down memory lane; it is a celebration of the spirit, battles, and triumphs that define Butler basketball.
Shelvin Mack stands as a towering figure in Butler lore, having played three seasons for the Bulldogs where he started 107 out of a possible 108 games. Mack’s leadership in the locker room and on the court was instrumental to his team’s success, with an impressive combined record of 87-21 during his playing career from 2008 to 2011. He played a pivotal role in guiding his team to consecutive National Championship appearances, showcasing his all-around skills with a stat line of 14.1 points per game, 4.2 rebounds per game, and 3.3 assists per game. While not always the most reliable shooter, it was Mack’s steady hand and unwavering commitment that truly solidified his legacy at Butler.
Kellen Dunham, a guard for the Butler basketball team from 2012 to 2016, was a mainstay in their starting lineup, starting 109 games out of a possible 134. Known for his versatility on both ends of the court, Dunham’s 6’6” frame would make him an ideal player in today’s basketball landscape. As the team’s sharpshooter, he connected on an impressive 38.5% of his three-point attempts, contributing to a successful run with three NCAA tournament appearances and an overall record of 86-48 under his leadership.
If only Gordon Hayward’s half-court heave had found its mark, Butler basketball might be held in even higher esteem. Hayward, a natural scorer and adept passer, is considered the face of modern Butler basketball, propelling the team to their first National Championship appearance. While success existed prior to his arrival, Hayward’s impact was undeniable, using his size, strength, and athleticism to dominate opponents on both ends of the court. His relentless effort and high-level play set a standard for incoming players, laying the foundation for Butler’s eventual entry into the competitive Big East conference.
As we reflect on these legendary players who have graced the courts of Hinkle Fieldhouse, we are reminded of the enduring legacy they have left on Butler basketball. Their unwavering commitment to excellence, passion for the game, and selfless team spirit have cemented their places not only in the annals of Butler basketball history but in the hearts of fans who have witnessed their remarkable feats on the court. The Butler Bulldogs’ all-time starting five represents not just a team, but a legacy of greatness that continues to inspire generations of basketball enthusiasts.
